Michael WallmanDISTRICT 8
Policies & Docs

Privacy, Cameras, and Smart Policing

Public safety is a civic duty — not an excuse for surveillance networks that outlive their promises and put our privacy at risk.

DraftPublic SafetyUpdated

This is a working draft. It will change, and comments are welcome.

Residents should not have to deploy private surveillance systems because of crime; public safety remains a fundamental civic duty. While no one argues against alerts for stolen cars or violent fugitives, that is not what this technology is about. We are witnessing the creeping importation of authoritarian monitoring models — reminiscent of how governments like China use facial recognition to track citizens and suppress dissent — right into our own backyards.

Although proponents claim current cameras are restricted to license plates and basic vehicle attributes, hardware outlives software policies. As AI models rapidly evolve, these systems will easily cross the line into identifying individuals, tracking anyone in the city at any time, and morphing into automated data brokers that harvest our daily movements. Most concerning is that neither local police departments nor municipal governments possess the cybersecurity expertise required to defend against a future where sophisticated AI agents and foreign state actors can effortlessly breach networked municipal databases.

If any cameras are used at all, they should be strictly closed-circuit and limited solely to anonymous data like traffic counts and speed, completely devoid of vehicle or user identifications. Ultimately, the speculative benefits of these surveillance networks do not outweigh the profound dangers to our civil liberties and digital security. Rather than investing heavily in fragile, invasive technology, I recommend that the council instead direct those resources toward hiring additional police officers.

I'll send a note when there's something new to read.